
Before leaving the house last night I watched the Knicks struggling through yet another one of their vain com comeback attempts. Anyone who has watched or seen the Knicks live in person this year knows the trend pretty well. They fall behind by a twenty-point margin in the first half and then the reserves Renaldo Balkman, Jamal Crawford, David Lee and Nate Robinson start pressing and trapping all over the place and within minutes the lead has been cut to single digits. The fans then get excited, the garden becomes electric as everyone is shouting, clapping and chanting defense whenever the opponents have the ball. Unfortunately, except for that great comeback win last month against Denver ironically enough, these games usually end with a Knicks loss.
This cycle was about to repeat itself last night when, with less than two minutes left and Denver nursing a 19-point, Knick rookie guard Mardy Collins gave Nuggets guard J.R. Smith a hard foul as he was going for a breakaway dunk. It seems as if the Knicks were upset that Denver still had their starters in the game in spite of their sizable advantage, and coach Isaiah Thomas allegedly encouraged his players to give a hard foul to anyone driving to the basket. 
There are also a number of reasons why George Karl would not want to take his foot off the gas in a blowout victory of the Knicks, (1) anyone who has seen the Knicks celebrate a victory of the past year (especially Crawford and Robinson) knows that they can be a bit obnoxious, if not immature with all of their collar-popping and chest-pounding; (2) the Knicks came back and defeated the Nuggets’ starters last month and maybe Karl wanted to send a message to his players, and (3) Karl and former Knicks coach Larry Brown are both “North Carolina guys†and to be able to add on Thomas’s compounding miseries at the garden after the team’s falling out with Brown may be exactly what Karl desired.
In other words there are countless of speculative explanations for why this happened.
However, at the end of the day, we can not evade one very important fact, that yet again the Knicks were being sure-handedly defeated by an opponent. With as many breathtaking individual talents as they have on that roster (Steve Francis, Stephon Marbury and Nate Robinson), gifted role players (Balkman, Lee and Quentin Richardson), a sometimes dominant big man (Eddy Curry) and a highly underrated mercurial guard who has shown time and again he could make clutch shots (Jamal Crawford), they should not be falling behind by twenty-plus on a regular basis.
In many ways the Knicks remind me of the Miami Heat before they traded for
Shaq. Pat Riley was at his wits end with what to do with that team and he had but conceded that it’d be better to pass on the reins for developing talented youngsters Caron Butler, Udonis Haslem, Lamar Odom and Dwyayne Wade to Stan Van Gundy than continue watching his career winning percentage decline. Everyone knows about the happy ending that came last year when Shaq and Wade led the Heat to their first title in franchise history. However if you take into consideration that the Heat before Shaw had more individual talent than the Pistons team that beat Shaq’s last Lakers team, then, you could see that there’s a good chance that Miami would have won a championship with the team it had before Shaq. I still can not fault Riley for the gamble because obviously it has paid off. (I’ll have more to say on the Heat and Lakers in the next post).
What was instructive about Riley’s maneuverings with the Heat is that he was aware that his aura, methods and shadow was not relating to his young players. They all respected him and admired him, but at the end of the day were not necessarily that compelled to play for him or the way that he wanted. Riley realized that it’s too hard and too awkward being president and coach of a team. Both coaches and players rely on the distance created between them and management. Players need to feel as if they have someone in administration on their side, and so do coaches. If a coach is the team president, then the players have no real allies that they can trust in management, and that sometimes undermines trust between teammates, in the sense that they come to really hate anyone who’s a coaches’ favorite.
To put in context, imagine if you are a junior associate for a billion dollar firm and your firm’s president was just made your immediate supervisor. Would you feel comfortable going to work everyday?
It may be harder for coaches to be GMs in the NFL because of the complex salary cap structure, but it’s just as hard for NBA coaches to be Presidents of their organizations because of the intimate relationships between players and their coaches. The two of them need to be able to yell and make up without a real fear of getting fired or disproportionately punished. Right now the Knicks are not offering that to their players and James Dolan’s “now or never†or “one year to turn things around†declarations to Thomas are not helping anyone. Isaiah Thomas so desperately did not want to lose his job last year that he did a very human mistake and agreed to take on another person’s job.
We’ve all been there before. You start seeing your co-workers getting laid off, so you start making yourself extremely valuable to the corporation and in turn fail to see that you are killing your own value, if not values.
If Thomas wants to help his team to start playing better then he should take a page from Riley and Don Nelson and re-configure his organization. First he should resign from coaching and name Mark Aguirre head coach a position he deserves for the great work that he’s done with Eddy Curry and the respect that Richardson and others in the locker room have for him. Aguirre has the ideal coaching DNA very good player, but not a superstar, it allows players to respect his league ballin’ credentials as well as his intellect as a coach. Plus he’s worked under Brown, Thomas and Herb Williams the last three Knicks coaches so he will not make any dramatic changes to the system.
Next step is hire someone from Donnie Nelson’s office in Dallas or RC Buford’s office in San Antonio to help him manage the salary-cap. The trades that the Knicks make over the next two years will have dramatic impacts on the future of the organization. It’s one thing to trade marginal players for bad contracts, but they now have to be really afraid of not mortgaging the franchise. Plus, Thomas needs someone to tell him to stop buying out players in the final year of their deals. The Jalen Rose contract could have helped them get rid of Jerome James or Malik Rose, and the same goes for Maurice Taylor’s package.
Finally Thomas goes back to doing what he does best charming people with his charisma and really work to enhance his profile as one of the best-draft pick analysts in the NBA. In his tenure as GM of the Knicks and Raptors he has drafted the following
group of players Damon Stoudamire, Marcus Camby, Tracy McGrady, Vince Carter, David Lee, Channing Frye, Renaldo Balkman and Nate Robinson, which by all accounts would still make the core of a very good NBA team today. MSG needs people in the seats and an ambassador two things that if Thomas focuses his energies on he’d excel at immeasurably.
I do not want to make the claim that this the Knicks only or best option for turning their season around, but for anyone who’s seen the team play can attest to, it says a lot that the players with the least at stake and therefore largest margin for error are the only ones that can be counted on the most. Before they know it the mid-season mark will be upon them, and like these twenty-six point deficits, their low placing in the division will also prove insurmountable.
The Nightshift Chronicler